Monday, March 10, 2008

PRICE DISCRIMINATION

PRICE DISCRIMINATION

http://www.news.com/8301-10784_3-9715959-7.html

This news article presents the question, “Should Amazon.com be able to charge you more than someone else?” Acknowledging the newly achieved ability for Internet retailers to view buyer’s history and generate an adjusted price accordingly while guessing a maximum value at which the buyer would be willing to purchase an item. Applicable to not only Amazon.com, this technology can be exploited by any online retailer so as to maximize profit. The article finally asks whether or not “online price discrimination” presents a legitimate concern, because price discrimination is so commonplace anyway (grocery stores, airlines, movie theatres utilize this technique), and if not exact, a slightly inflated set price could lose considerable amounts of potential buyers. Furthermore, the nature of the Internet presents two obstacles for achieving effective PD; online shoppers are very price sensitive, and they talk a lot (price tracking would become considerably easy).

I don’t think online price discrimination is avoidable as technology advances allow further profiling to occur. But I also don’t think it is as much of a threat as it is an annoyance. Buyers have the freedom to not buy an item if they feel the price is too high, especially because I’m assuming most Internet shoppers are purchasing relatively elastic goods (luxuries). I don’t see major issue with price discrimination as long as buyers know what they’re dealing with and take the initiative to research other prices before buying. If a monopoly somehow does occurs, full control over prices would exist independent upon price discrimination, because if a buyer really wants and item, he or she can purchase it at one price only. Having to constantly check competing prices is probably a habit for typical online shoppers anyway, so price discrimination only may devastate those who are unaware of what’s going on (or are simply new to online purchasing). Price discrimination seems like a gamble for online retailers, in that exploiting such a technique may result in some advantageous gains, however because of how fast information travels online, someone speaking out could tarnish a sites popularity and lose significant amounts of buyers.

4 comments:

JOSH said...

Dave, again i venture into the unknown land of primary posting.


I think that it is alright to use the online discrimination for selling products. Like you said, most of the things you are buying over amazon.com are not necessary goods. People can choose to say, "hey i don't really need those $150 jordans" and if they still WANT them, they can also say, "i can go to some retail store and get them for less, if i can just get off my butt" If the online goods were necessary goods, and that was the only way to get them, i would say that it is then venturing into the monopoly range and should be stopped.

Lucas S. said...

I'm going to "venture" into Dave's blog too Josh, if that's ok.

In "venturing," by recognizing that online price discrimination exists and by stating the claims made by you two, I agree with the idea that this has become more of a nuisance then something of a worry economically. Producers are always looking to maximize their profit, "venturing" into ways to exploit consumers (like amazon.com) because they realize that their customers usually rely solely on them when buying goods. It's kind of like a game of "cat and mouse," those buyers who are "venturing" into the land of online shopping for the first time are more likely to be taken advantage of. I therefore have no problem with it. It almost makes the buying of a product "fun" and rewarding in a way, knowing that you were able to "out-smart" the producer once you've found a better price. But just as you both said, this is only true for elastic goods. Price discrimination on the inelastic level "ventures" into a different and unethical level. (just trying to keep the "venture" trend going...)

JohnKotz said...

I would agree that online price discrimination is ok because people have chosen to accept the fact that they will be paying more, but are buying from teh convenience of their own computer and do not have to drive to a store to get what they want. The choice is there but people choose to buy over the internet.

martywiese said...

As others have already stated, I also agree that price discrimination is ok... It sucks if you're on the end of the scale for people with more inelastic demand (and therefore have to pay less), but as a poor high school student with a crappy part-time job, it can come in handy.

I went to a movie last Friday at Whitewater and because of my student ID I only had to pay a fraction of the normal price. I'm assuming this qualifies as price discrimination in the sense that Whitewater (a college town with many broke students) knows that if it wants to get a large percentage of the population to attend its theatre, it's going to have to make it affordable for those who want to do something Friday night but can't afford anything pricy lest they run out of money to buy their ramen. Nonstudents, on the other hand, are most likely adults with steady incomes that would go to the movies regardless if the price was jacked up an extra dollar or two (after all, people in Fort still go to the more-expensive Star Cinema in J.C. just as much as the theatre in Whitewater).

As far as online businesses go, I guess they need some way to compete. People who shop online are usually very computer-savvy anyway, and are going to shop around for the best price. (It's much less for them to do that in actual stores, after all.) Plus, the demand here is elastic (as aforementioned) and I'm sure most online shoppers would trade a slightly-lower price due to non-tracking by sites for the convenience they get by not having to move from their computer chairs and getting items shipped directly to them.