Tuesday, January 12, 2010

1 - Media Literacy, Movies, and McCarthy

Last spring I was in a seminar class called "McCarthy and The Movies." During the class we watched a variety of films that portrayed the ideas of Communism, McCarthyism, or both in some way. We learned how the filmmakers's thoughts and intended messages were interwoven not only into the plot but even in the technical aspects of the film through cinematic techniques of manipulating the mise-en-scene, lighting, camera angle, focus, etc. of the shot. By breaking down this "grammar" of the film, we were able to clearly see the stance of the film and how it was attempting to influence its audience.

How a character was portrayed often followed certain conventions. From a high camera angle, the subject looked weak and powerless, while from a low angle, he or she looked strong and even intimidating. In full, high-key lighting, subjects often appeared more friendly and trustworthy compared to those filmed in dark, or high-contrast lighting containing ominous shadows. Such brief examples of direct manipulation demonstrate some simple, key ways a filmmaker can change the audience's perception of the subject without any further doing.

As a typical viewer watches a film, his or her "autopilot" kicks in and they subconsciously interpret what is being presented. On this simple level, they may absorb representations of the subjects based only off of how the media is portraying them; autopilot provides no room for for contention. When shown a character that is a Communist in dark lighting, he or she may automatically associate Communism with bad, evil, or danger.

A more media "literate" viewer, however, will be conscious of these conventional tricks and therefore realize that "Communism = bad" is only the filmmaker's opinion; being aware of such manipulations consequently allows the viewer to turn off autopilot (even if just for a moment) and generate their own opinion free of potential bias.

In the end, it was interesting to see how just gaining a little more understanding of how the material was being presented completely changed an interpretation of a given film. By learning how cinematic techniques were manipulated and becoming more "media literate" in the process, I was able to see much more into a given message, increasing both my understanding and control over the message as well.

Sunday, April 20, 2008

21: Doors, Goats, and Confusion

Just last weekend I saw the new movie “21.” Not only did the movie make me certain that card-counting would be an ideal hobby, but it left me confused about a certain scenario presented by the professor in the film. For those of you who haven’t seen the movie or simply do not worry if you’ve understood everything you’ve seen or not, here is a reiteration of the situation:

The professor asks the student to pretend he’s on a game-show, and presents the contestant with 3 doors; behind one of the doors is a luxurious car, and behind the other two doors is a dud prize, a measly goat. The contestant chooses one door, and the host opens a different door to reveal a goat. The host then asks the contestant whether he would like to choose the other door, or stay with the door he originally picked. The student says that at first his chances of picking the car were 1/3, but now that “variable change” had been introduced, the chances of the remaining, unpicked door had a 2/3 chance of possessing the car. The professor then congratulates the student for his brilliance and informs him that he had won the (imaginary) car.

Even though the film had stated that it was clearly a better decision to switch doors, I could still not convince myself that the chance of choosing the goat or car between the two doors was NOT simply 50/50. No one I talked to, mainly Josh and my dad, could explain the situation either, but luckily I found an explanation for it:

http://mathforum.org/dr.math/faq/faq.monty.hall.html

One of the site’s explanation assumes that there is a winning door and that the two remaining doors, A and B, both have goats behind them. There are three options:
  1. The contestant first chooses the door with the car behind it. He is then shown either door A or door B, which reveals a goat. If he changes his choice of doors, he loses. If he stays with his original choice, he wins.
  2. The contestant first chooses door A. He is then shown door B, which has a goat behind it. If he switches to the remaining door, he wins the car. Otherwise, he loses.
  3. The contestant first chooses door B. He is then is shown door A, which has a goat behind it. If he switches to the remaining door, he wins the car. Otherwise, he loses.

Therefore, in the end, the contestant has a 1/3 chance of pursuing one of the three options. Ultimately, if he stays, he will win 1/3 times, but if he switches, he will win 2/3. Thus, the cost of not switching is TWICE the amount of switching. It's a stretch, but maybe someone could help me relate more of it to economics.

Sunday, April 6, 2008

Ethanol


http://www.illinoistimes.com/gyrobase/PrintFriendly?oid=oid%3A6787

The article describes a few specific cases in which cattle ranchers have lost revenue due to higher prices of corn as a result of the increased demand of ethanol.

Coinciding with the article, my externalities paper illustrated the effects of a higher demand for ethanol on the economy. In short, a higher demand for ethanol increases the demand for corn, the primary source for ethanol. As the demand for corn increases, so does the price. The surrounding markets that rely on corn are also affected, for example a farmer that has to buy corn to feed his cattle must raise the price of his products in order to compensate for the raised price of corn as a resource. Therefore, dairy, beef, and any other markets that regularly execute a transaction for corn are ultimately affected.

Furthermore, the supply of products that compete for the same growing space as corn (like wheat and rice) are affected, in that as more corn takes the place of wheat or rice, the supply for wheat and rice decreases, raising the price in the process. The article provides the scenario of soybean acreage loss as soybeans compete for the same land as corn. While soybeans remain a major component of trans-fat-free foods, price pressure is engendered for products such as potato chips, fried chicken, etc.

Provided the various benefits of using ethanol as a fuel additive (such as its ability to increase oxygen levels in gasoline and reduce pollution over 50% as compared to gasoline), I still think promoting and developing this alternative fuel remains a more significant priority at this point in time, even if it means losing a few cents on various food products.

Monday, March 10, 2008

PRICE DISCRIMINATION

PRICE DISCRIMINATION

http://www.news.com/8301-10784_3-9715959-7.html

This news article presents the question, “Should Amazon.com be able to charge you more than someone else?” Acknowledging the newly achieved ability for Internet retailers to view buyer’s history and generate an adjusted price accordingly while guessing a maximum value at which the buyer would be willing to purchase an item. Applicable to not only Amazon.com, this technology can be exploited by any online retailer so as to maximize profit. The article finally asks whether or not “online price discrimination” presents a legitimate concern, because price discrimination is so commonplace anyway (grocery stores, airlines, movie theatres utilize this technique), and if not exact, a slightly inflated set price could lose considerable amounts of potential buyers. Furthermore, the nature of the Internet presents two obstacles for achieving effective PD; online shoppers are very price sensitive, and they talk a lot (price tracking would become considerably easy).

I don’t think online price discrimination is avoidable as technology advances allow further profiling to occur. But I also don’t think it is as much of a threat as it is an annoyance. Buyers have the freedom to not buy an item if they feel the price is too high, especially because I’m assuming most Internet shoppers are purchasing relatively elastic goods (luxuries). I don’t see major issue with price discrimination as long as buyers know what they’re dealing with and take the initiative to research other prices before buying. If a monopoly somehow does occurs, full control over prices would exist independent upon price discrimination, because if a buyer really wants and item, he or she can purchase it at one price only. Having to constantly check competing prices is probably a habit for typical online shoppers anyway, so price discrimination only may devastate those who are unaware of what’s going on (or are simply new to online purchasing). Price discrimination seems like a gamble for online retailers, in that exploiting such a technique may result in some advantageous gains, however because of how fast information travels online, someone speaking out could tarnish a sites popularity and lose significant amounts of buyers.

Sunday, February 24, 2008

Vulnerability and Foreign Oil

http://priceofoil.org/2007/04/24/mccain-warns-of-vulnerability-of-foreign-oil/

The article I found reiterates republican candidate John McCain’s third response to three major policy addresses. In short, Senator McCain presents the “great and urgent challenge — breaking our nation’s critical dependence on foreign sources of oil”. McCain admits that oil will always remain a necessity, and as we account for 25% of the world demand for this resource, we only possess 3% of proven reserves. The senator argues that “most of the world’s known reserves are in the Persian Gulf, in the hands of dictators or nationalized oil companies. Its availability and price are manipulated by a cartel of countries where our values aren’t typically shared and our interests aren’t their first priority.”

In relation to the all familiar supply curve, it may be easily recognized that a downward shift in supply noticeably jacks up the price of the product in question. This further verifies the evident vulnerability the U.S. finds itself all too accustomed to, in that while the supply of oil is controlled by unstable nations, the odds of maintaining a reasonable price of oil are undeniably threatened. It is clear that foreign dependency in such a case is far from ideal.

Monday, February 11, 2008

INCENTIVES

http://www.cameratown.com/news/news.cfm/hurl/id%7C4789

The article compares starting prices, the ending sale prices, and the (actual) online value. It makes it easy to see how prices are manipulated and how sales may actually make you pay more money.

I wrote this before finding the article:

I don’t know how well this applies, but it seems as if other companies, such as store retailers, make it so clothes seem to always be on sale. The buyer might think he or she is actually getting a better deal on the item, however the actual worth of the item might just be what price the clothes are currently listed at (or less). Seeing that the clothes are “25%” off appeals to the buyer for various reasons. First off, they would think that they are getting a bargain, and secondly, a sale typically is not meant to be forever, which would imply that the price will eventually raise and the buyer must therefore hurry up and purchase the item before it goes off-sale, potentially not analyzing his or her other options.

If this is true, then two pieces of clothing of identical worth could be listed at completely different sale percents, however the end price would be the same. Say clothing #1 is listed at $80 at first, with a 50% off sign, leaving it at $40. Clothing #2 (an item of equal worth, but in a different store) starts at $50, and with a 20% off sign it becomes again $40. A buyer, seeing the first item listed at a higher price and assuming that the value of the bargain is all he or she is considering , might lean towards purchasing the first (the seemingly more valuable one) as opposed to the “less valuable” #2. In other words, jacking up the price and compensating it with an appropriate sale might actually appeal to buyers.

I don’t know if this is even a valid argument or idea. I was just looking at the ability for dealers to offer all these “incentives” (noted in the article and example analysis on the main page), and questioning the legitimacy of those that are offered.