Sunday, April 20, 2008

21: Doors, Goats, and Confusion

Just last weekend I saw the new movie “21.” Not only did the movie make me certain that card-counting would be an ideal hobby, but it left me confused about a certain scenario presented by the professor in the film. For those of you who haven’t seen the movie or simply do not worry if you’ve understood everything you’ve seen or not, here is a reiteration of the situation:

The professor asks the student to pretend he’s on a game-show, and presents the contestant with 3 doors; behind one of the doors is a luxurious car, and behind the other two doors is a dud prize, a measly goat. The contestant chooses one door, and the host opens a different door to reveal a goat. The host then asks the contestant whether he would like to choose the other door, or stay with the door he originally picked. The student says that at first his chances of picking the car were 1/3, but now that “variable change” had been introduced, the chances of the remaining, unpicked door had a 2/3 chance of possessing the car. The professor then congratulates the student for his brilliance and informs him that he had won the (imaginary) car.

Even though the film had stated that it was clearly a better decision to switch doors, I could still not convince myself that the chance of choosing the goat or car between the two doors was NOT simply 50/50. No one I talked to, mainly Josh and my dad, could explain the situation either, but luckily I found an explanation for it:

http://mathforum.org/dr.math/faq/faq.monty.hall.html

One of the site’s explanation assumes that there is a winning door and that the two remaining doors, A and B, both have goats behind them. There are three options:
  1. The contestant first chooses the door with the car behind it. He is then shown either door A or door B, which reveals a goat. If he changes his choice of doors, he loses. If he stays with his original choice, he wins.
  2. The contestant first chooses door A. He is then shown door B, which has a goat behind it. If he switches to the remaining door, he wins the car. Otherwise, he loses.
  3. The contestant first chooses door B. He is then is shown door A, which has a goat behind it. If he switches to the remaining door, he wins the car. Otherwise, he loses.

Therefore, in the end, the contestant has a 1/3 chance of pursuing one of the three options. Ultimately, if he stays, he will win 1/3 times, but if he switches, he will win 2/3. Thus, the cost of not switching is TWICE the amount of switching. It's a stretch, but maybe someone could help me relate more of it to economics.

6 comments:

Tanvirkamal said...

now THAT makes more sense, I remember you and josh talking about that and I had no idea how to tell you how it worked either but I had heard about it before I think in some class with Mrs. Dowgwillo but either way it is kinda weird how it works out but I guess it makes sense. To relate it to econ, I guess your relation is as good as mine in that I don't really have one.

fileben said...

This is awesome, because my dad and I were just talking about this when we were watching 'deal or no deal' a couple weeks ago. it was a weird one with 10 million dollar cases and 10 'loser' cases. the lady chose one, then eliminated them down to 3 million dollar cases and 2 'loser' cases. I said she should switch the cases (i think they're allowed to do that, right?), and my dad said no. We argued about it for a while, and I had to revert to this game show situation. He eventually agreed with me (a rare occasion). It's much easier to see if you simply make a bigger pool of goats. say, 100 doors, 99 goats, 1 car. Yeah, that's my only economic application, so i guess it just works for deal or no deal at this point.

KM said...

There is always economic implications and applications, Grasshopper(s). (Okay, if you never saw Kung Fu, you're totally not getting that, but it's okay)

Game theory at it's finest. Although me, with my math-iness not as complete as some of you, would say that the guy actually had a 67% chance of being in the RIGHT place if he didn't switch. Why? 1/3 for each door, right? If the car is not in the first door opened, stay where you are becuase you have a 2/3 chance of being right.

But I suppose, with that logic, you also have a 2/3 chance of being wrong.

Yeah. I know nothing about math.

JOSH said...

Dave.

I like this post. i know you were talking to me about it after the movie and i am with you that card counting seems to be a very productive pasttime.
I get your idea and i get the contection between that and game theory for economics. I was talking with my mom this past weekend though, and she was somewhat skeptical; wondering if the choices were somewhat exclusive? However, the idea is strictly on the principal that you are picking wrong 67 percent of time on your first choice. I tried to convince her but i'm not sure she bought it. i don't know if it's cause she is catching something that we're not, or she is just scared about us making lots of $$$$!

EssenceofErika said...

I can't grasp this half as well as I'd like...maybe if I switched to the other side of my brain...would I have 2/3 chances of winning that way?!?

Lucas S. said...

I think it's very weird how a situation can at first seem so complex, like there's no possible way your brain is going to be able to process how or why this works. But then, once your given the explanation, it seems so simple (coming down to being able to differentiate a goat from a car). This just goes to show another way that math can make the mind think differently than usual.